criterionforum.org

Darth Lavender wrote:I'm increasingly convinced the film SHOULD be 1.66:1

miless wrote:I doubt Kubrick intended 2001 to be 1.66.

fdm wrote:Likely Zodiac will be coming along fairly soon.

davidhare wrote:I assume this is now a Universal version. Err so to speak.

Er bestaan twee versies van The Shining. De Europese versie, die 119 minuten speeltijd heeft. In de Verenigde Staten is The Shining uitgebracht in de originele bioscoopversie, die ruim 25 minuten langer duurt.

chaddoli wrote:Yes I am definitely interested in the Kubricks, especially Eyes Wide Shut. But why isn't there a box?

miless wrote:I doubt Kubrick intended 2001 to be 1.66.

But I could see him preferring it on those films he shot open matte.

fdm wrote:I'll avoid mentioning stuff that most here would poo-poo on, but check out Lives Of Others and Pan's Labyrinth. Reds too. Possibly The Fountain (depends on what you like); and Bonnie & Clyde -- but there I go...

Some titles I've got my eye on (coming later this year) are Becket and the (newly restored) Godfather trilogy. And also How The West Was Won.

Likely Zodiac will be coming along fairly soon.

(Of the Kubricks, I was most disappointed in Clockwork Orange, it's PQ was the least "hi-def" of the bunch; still haven't gotten around to Full Metal Jacket. Eyes Wide Shut and The Shining are probably my favorites, mostly because I think I've seen 2001 too many times - but it too was pretty stunning, looked and sounded wonderful. I've never quite made it to the DVD version of Barry Lyndon, putting it off thinking that it was going to be put out in hi-def, but no such luck.)

Also highly recommend Blade Runner and The Fifth Element if you like that sort of thing. I'd put Blade Runner in the same category as 2001, probably seen it too many times, but the blu-ray made it almost seem like watching it again for the first time. Fifth Element equally so.

chaddoli wrote:Also, is the PS3 region free? I have a feeling it's not, which is incredibly lame. Does a hack exist? Red Desert on BR in the UK makes my mouth water....

chaddoli wrote:Also, is the PS3 region free? I have a feeling it's not, which is incredibly lame. Does a hack exist? Red Desert on BR in the UK makes my mouth water.

fdm wrote:

chaddoli wrote:Also, is the PS3 region free? I have a feeling it's not, which is incredibly lame. Does a hack exist? Red Desert on BR in the UK makes my mouth water.

You may still be able to play it if the disk is "region free"... (I have no idea.)

Rufus T. Firefly wrote:Dr Strangelove in December, Taxi Driver in February.

bkimball wrote:Notice the list price of $30. A true sign of prices coming down from $40?

Mr. Ebert wrote:Tarsem's "The Fall" is a mad folly, an extravagant visual orgy, a free-fall from reality into uncharted realms. Surely it is one of the wildest indulgences a director has ever granted himself. Tarsem, for two decades a leading director of music videos and TV commercials, spent millions of his own money to finance "The Fall," filmed it for four years in 28 countries and has made a movie that you might want to see for no other reason than because it exists.

There will never be another like it.

"The Fall" is so audacious that when Variety calls it a "vanity project," you can only admire the man vain enough to make it. It tells a simple story with vast romantic images so stunning I had to check twice, three times, to be sure the film actually claims to have absolutely no computer-generated imagery. None? What about the Labyrinth of Despair, with no exit? The intersecting walls of zig-zagging staircases? The man who emerges from the burning tree? Perhaps the key words are "computer-generated." Perhaps some of the images are created by more traditional kinds of special effects.

The story framework for the imagery is straightforward. In Los Angeles, circa 1915, a silent movie stunt man has his legs paralyzed while performing a reckless stunt. He convalesces in a half-deserted hospital, its corridors of cream and lime stretching from ward to ward of mostly empty beds, their pillows and sheets awaiting the harvest of World War I. The stunt man is Roy (Lee Pace), pleasant in appearance, confiding in speech, happy to make a new friend of a little girl named Alexandria (Catinca Untaru).

Roy tells a story to Alexandria, involving adventurers who change appearance as quickly as a child's imagination can do its work. We see the process. He tells her of an "Indian" who has a wigwam and a squaw. She does not know these words, and envisions an Indian from a land of palaces, turbans and swamis. The verbal story is input from Roy; the visual story is output from Alexandria.

The story involves Roy (playing the Black Bandit) and his friends: a bomb-throwing Italian anarchist, an escaped African slave, an Indian (from India), and Charles Darwin and his pet monkey, Wallace. Their sworn enemy, Governor Odious, has stranded them on a desert island, but they come ashore (riding swimming elephants, of course) and wage war on him.

Roy draws out the story for a personal motive; after Alexandria brings him some communion wafers from the hospital chapel, he persuades her to steal some morphine tablets from the dispensary. Paralyzed and having lost his great love (she is the Princess in his story), he hopes to kill himself. There is a wonderful scene of the little girl trying to draw him back to life.

Either you are drawn into the world of this movie or you are not. It is preposterous, of course, but I vote with Werner Herzog, who says if we do not find new images, we will perish. Here a line of bowmen shoot hundreds of arrows into the air. So many of them fall into the back of the escaped slave that he falls backward and the weight of his body is supported by them, as on a bed of nails with dozens of foot-long arrows. There is scene of the monkey Wallace chasing a butterfly through impossible architecture.

At this point in reviews of movies like "The Fall" (not that there are any), I usually announce that I have accomplished my work. I have described what the movie does, how it looks while it is doing it, and what the director has achieved. Well, what has he achieved? "The Fall" is beautiful for its own sake. And there is the sweet charm of the young Romanian actress Catinca Untaru, who may have been dubbed for all I know, but speaks with the innocence of childhood, working her way through tangles of words. She regards with equal wonder the reality she lives in, and the fantasy she pretends to. It is her imagination that creates the images of Roy's story, and they have a purity and power beyond all calculation. Roy is her perfect storyteller, she is his perfect listener, and together they build a world.

Ebert notes: The movie's R rating should not dissuade bright teenagers from this celebration of the imagination.

Dennis Harvey-Variety wrote:Many thought Tarsem's 2000 serial-killer thriller "The Cell" defined the trend of TV commercial/musicvid whizzes making movies composed of 95% visual flash -- but they ain't seen nothin' yet. Soph effort "The Fall" is an absurdly elaborate package oblivious to the interests of any audience beyond its own wildly indulged creator. This convoluted, arbitrary, overlong whimsy will strike most grown-ups as childish, and is far too violent and pretentious for kids. Pic's sheer curiosity value should win some defenders, but will pose a very tough sell. Best prospects perhaps lie in drastic re-cutting for family DVD markets.

There's something appalling about a vanity project that takes this much time, money and energy to make (shot in nearly two dozen countries). Nor can Tarsem claim the visionary entitlement of past large-scale art cinema masters like Jodorowsky or Tarkovsky, because the only thing behind his stunning pictures is an advertising genius' instinct for the "wow" image. Those work best in isolation, though, not in two-hour compilations.

While "The Fall" does score points for sheer originality, ambition and perversity of concept, the film is based on a 1981 Bulgarian pic, "Yo Ho Ho," written by Valeri Petrov, in which all the major ideas in "The Fall" already exist. That earlier film (directed by Zako Heskija) was by all accounts cheap and charming, whereas the new edition has neither of those attributes.

After a railroad-bridge-plunge prologue whose every slo-mo B&W shot is self-consciously wrought, we enter the color world of Los Angeles "a long, long time ago" (circa 1915, by the looks of things). Convalescing in the children's ward of a hospital is Alexandria (Catinca Untaru), a spirited tot with a broken arm. Bored, the child tosses a note from her window to nurse Evelyn (Justine Waddell), but it's blown instead into the lap of bedridden young man Roy (Lee Pace) on another floor. He's been paralyzed in the aforementioned bridge stunt, performed for a silent Western feature.

Roy befriends the tyke, holding her attention by spinning a fantastical tale about five larger-than-life heroes: masked swashbuckler the Black Bandit (Pace), muscle-bound escaped African slave Otta Benga (Marcus Wesley), an Indian mystic (Julian Bleach), Italian anarchist Luigi (Robin Smith), and naturalist Charles Darwin (Leo Bill), all of whom have been banished to a desert isle.

Escaping, they vow vengeance on shared nemesis Governor Odious (Daniel Caltagirone), kidnapping his fiancee (Waddell) and finally facing off against the Gov.'s armed hordes.

Visualized by Alexandria, these characters are played by hospital residents and staff in extravagant disguise (costumes flashily designed by Eiko Ishioka). Their already capricious adventures gain additional eccentricity from a 5-year-old's imagination. But Tarsem evinces no lightness of touch or flair for action set pieces. Instead, the fantasy segs -- shot on exotic locations from Turkey to Cambodia to Chile to Prague -- offer a cold pageantry that might be better suited for a Matthew Barney epic.

The hospital sequences take a morbid turn, but Tarsem lacks the deftness of touch to make the development touching rather than grotesque, despite good adult/child thesp chemistry. Untaru is a charmer, despite being saddled with precocious dialogue.

With everything from underwater shots of pachyderms swimming to massed sufi dancers to Brothers Quay-type animation, "The Fall" doesn't lack for amazing sights. But they lack an ingratiating context, and what goodwill the pic does conjure is betrayed in last reel, accompanied by a rote antiwar message; effects are so misjudged they're commensurate with someone cutting "Girls Gone Wild" clips into "The Little Mermaid."

Happy ending feels like a formulaic afterthought; the sentimentality "Fall" occasionally strives for never convinces.

What Tarsem has created is basically a coffee-table book of striking travelogue images masquerading as a mix of warm-hearted period drama and fantasy. Aesthetically sumptuous, technically often remarkable, "The Fall" is nonetheless an alienating experience --a white elephant at once enthralled by its own rarefied distance from basic human interest.

All visual design contribs are superb, though the music is bombastic.

MichaelB wrote:

fdm wrote:

chaddoli wrote:Also, is the PS3 region free? I have a feeling it's not, which is incredibly lame. Does a hack exist? Red Desert on BR in the UK makes my mouth water.

You may still be able to play it if the disk is "region free"... (I have no idea.)

Well, the BFI's other Blu-Ray, Salò, isn't region-coded...