criterionforum.org

domino harvey wrote: Wed Oct 29, 2025 3:40 pm For my Letterboxd bros: Reminder that the greatest music video of all time, “Let Forever Be,” is eligible this year

Nice try, but I do believe that award goes to Windowlicker, with All Is Full Of Love & Afrika Shox coming in close behind (and all eligible for 1999!), making a good case for doing shorts & videos separately from ful-length films (because there's already enough competition from just films).

Lowry_Sam wrote: Fri Nov 07, 2025 12:05 am I take it these are all 2000? Some are listed on IMDB under 1999 (festival dates?) despite having 2000 release dated & wanted to make sure:
American Psycho
High Fidelity
Water Drops On Burning Rocks

Yes, these are all for 2000. Actually, I'm not aware of any 1999 festival dates for any of these films. I've added your two other 1999 requests.

As for Chris Cunningham, his series of Nissan commercials is also rather stunning

Another missing is Peau Neuve.

Lowry_Sam wrote: Fri Nov 07, 2025 7:27 am Another missing is Peau Neuve.

Added

Please add:
Besat (Anders Rønnow Klarlund)
Post Mortem (Louis Bélanger)
Sunshine (István Szabó)
Ba mùa (Tony Bui)
C'est quoi la vie? (François Dupeyron)
Haut les coeurs! (Sólveig Anspach)
Caofangzi (Geng Xu)

Please add Adam Curtis’s documentary The Mayfair Set.

All added, thanks

I hope everyone has watched, and is voting for, The Winslow Boy. I’m glad Mamet didn’t wind up just being another Branagh adapting his favorite plays, but this one is such a perfect fit to his obsession with games and the truth. Also this is probably Pidgeon’s best performance.

Can you please add the House on Haunted Hill remake?

Added

Thanks! Can you add Mike Figgis’ Miss Julie, Made Men, and Thick as Thieves as well?

Done

Thanks! This is an incredible year, I can’t remember the last time I needed to do a full 25 (and even still I had to cut titles)

It has proven to be so good. Even my disappointments were relative as there was something to recommend. I have no clue how I’m going to trim down to a list.

Not sure how I missed seeing this wasn't on the list, but if you can add Morita's Keiho - one of my two favorite movies of 1999 - I'll, of course, vote for it. So sad no one else is missing it.

Wasn't familiar with it but I've enjoyed other Morita films. Added!

Thanks for your work!

Keiho is an exceptionally well-configured detective-story/psycho-thriller/courtroom-drama, part Hillside Stranglers, part Hamlet, with all the pictorial, editorial, and absurdist genius of, well, a top Morita film. [No one compares.] The narrative is complex and the side characters are hilarious. Quiet Detective Nagoshi (the always unforgettable Kishibe Ittoku) never stops chewing his gum and even spits, loudly, in close-up; seems crazier than the suspected psychopath he tracks, absurdly counting down ("5, 4, 3, ,2, 1") then clapping his hands in his suspect's face during interrogations. The state prosecutor constantly mumbles, his brow furrowed, his eyes, mole-like, rarely open. The aging court psychiatrist's young assistant is named Kafuka. Etc. etc.

Could you please add Whiteboyz (Levin)?

Added

Can you add Otomo (https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0204527/) and Pelísky (https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0167331)? Surprised the latter isn't already there!

Added

The 1999 List



##. Film (Director) points/votes(top 5 placements, aka likely votes in decade list)/highest ranking

01. Eyes Wide Shut (Stanley Kubrick) 339/16(11)/1(x3)
02. Ghost Dog: The Way of the Samurai (Jim Jarmusch) 271/16(5)/2(x2)
03. Beau Travail (Claire Denis) 266/13(9)/1(x3)
04. Magnolia (Paul Thomas Anderson) 250/15(5)/1
05. Election (Alexander Payne) 245/16(3)/2
06. The Straight Story (David Lynch) 217/15(3)/2(x2)
07. باد ما را خواهد برد [Bad ma ra khahad bord] [The Wind Will Carry Us] (Abbas Kiarostami) 202/11(6)/1(x3)
08. The Virgin Suicides (Sofia Coppola) 199/13(6)/1(x2)
09. eXistenZ (David Cronenberg) 198/14(1)/4
10. Todo sobre mi madre [All About My Mother] (Pedro Almodóvar) 193/12(5)/1(x2)
11. Rosetta (Jean-Pierre & Luc Dardenne) 192/12(5)/1
12. Being John Malkovich (Spike Jonze) 175/11(4)/2(x2)
13. The Insider (Michael Mann) 151/10(2)/4
14. The Limey (Steven Soderbergh) 142/12(2)/3(x2)
15. Outer Space (Peter Tscherkassky) 136/8(1)/1
16. The Iron Giant (Brad Bird) 129/8(3)/1
17. Bringing Out the Dead (Martin Scorsese) 124/9(1)/2
18. Fight Club (David Fincher) 113/7(1)/5
19. L'Humanité [Humanity] (Bruno Dumont) 111/7(3)/3
20. The Talented Mr. Ripley (Anthony Minghella) 105/9/6
21. カリスマ [Karisuma] [Charisma] (Kiyoshi Kurosawa) 98/5(3)/3(x2)
(tie) Le Temps retrouvé [Time Regained] (Raúl Ruiz) 98/6(2)/4(x2)
23. Ça commence aujourd'hui [It All Starts Today] (Bertrand Tavernier) 96/6(2)/1(x2)
24. Dick (Andrew Fleming) 93/6(2)/1
25. Julien Donkey-Boy (Harmony Korine) 91/5(2)/1
26. Sweet and Lowdown (Woody Allen) 90/6(1)/5
27. Three Kings (David O. Russell) 86/7(2)/4(x2)
28. Belfast, Maine (Frederick Wiseman) 83/6(1)/5
29. The Matrix (Lana & Lilly Wachowski) 82/7/8
30. The Chemical Brothers: Let Forever Be (Michel Gondry) 81/4(3)/2
31. The Winslow Boy (David Mamet) 80/5(2)/3
32. Office Space (Mike Judge) 79/5(2)/1
33. Topsy-Turvy (Mike Leigh) 75/5(2)/3
34. Ratcatcher (Lynne Ramsay) 74/5(1)/3
35. Galaxy Quest (Dean Parisot) 68/5(1)/1
(tie) Jesus' Son (Alison Maclean) 68/5(1)/2
37. Felicia's Journey (Atom Egoyan) 62/4/6
38. 鎗火 [Cheung foh] [The Mission] (Johnnie To) 57/3(2)/3
39. South Park: Bigger, Longer & Uncut (Trey Parker) 56/6(1)/5
40. Titus (Julie Taymor) 53/3/7
41. American Movie (Chris Smith) 52/4(1)/2
42. 一个都不能少 [Yi ge dou bu neng shao] [Not One Less] (Zhang Yimou) 51/4(1)/3
(tie) Pola X (Leos Carax) 51/4(1)/3
44. 박하사탕 [Bakha satang] [Peppermint Candy] (Lee Chang-dong) 49/5/6
45. Sicilia! (Jean-Marie Straub & Danièle Huillet) 48/4(1)/3
46. Spaced (1999-2001) (Edgar Wright) 47/3(1)/4
47. Boys Don't Cry (Kimberly Peirce) 45/2(2)/2
48. La Lettre [A Carta] [The Letter] (Manoel de Oliveira) 43/3(1)/3
49. As Bodas de Deus (João César Monteiro) 42/3/8
(tie) Persian Series (1999-2001) (Stan Brakhage) 42/4/9

ALSO-RANS

Au cœur du mensonge [The Color of Lies] (Claude Chabrol) 40/5/12
Sleepy Hollow (Tim Burton) 39/3/7
American Beauty (Sam Mendes) 39/4(1)/5
Mr. Death: The Rise and Fall of Fred A. Leuchter, Jr. (Errol Morris) 39/3/7
Toy Story 2 (John Lasseter) 36/2/7
The Sixth Sense (M. Night Shyamalan) 36/4/12
Holy Smoke (Jane Campion) 36/5/10
那山那人那狗 [Na shan na ren na gou] [Postmen in the Mountains] (Huo Jianqi) 35/2/6
Aphex Twin: Windowlicker (Chris Cunningham) 35/3/11(x2)
Молох [Moloch] (Aleksandr Sokurov) 35/4/9

Mayıs Sıkıntısı [Clouds of May] (Nuri Bilge Ceylan) 32/2/7
Dogma (Kevin Smith) 31/4/11
我的父亲母亲 [Wo de fu qin mu qin] [The Road Home] (Zhang Yimou) 30/2(1)/4
Romance X [Romance] (Catherine Breillat) 30/2/7
The End of the Affair (Neil Jordan) 30/3/6
Summer of Sam (Spike Lee) 30/4/14
Ravenous (Antonia Bird) 29/2(1)/5
Fuori dal mondo [Not of This World] (Giuseppe Piccioni) 29/2/11
The Ninth Gate (Roman Polański) 29/4/7
Any Given Sunday (Oliver Stone) 27/2/6
Mein liebster Feind – Klaus Kinski [My Best Fiend] (Werner Herzog) 27/3/6

ホーホケキョとなりの山田くん [Hōhokekyo tonari no yamada-kun] [My Neighbours the Yamadas] (Isao Takahata) 26/2/12
The Blair Witch Project (Daniel Myrick & Eduardo Sánchez) 25/2/10
Il mio viaggio in Italia [My Voyage to Italy] (Martin Scorsese) 24/2/9
Buena Vista Social Club (Wim Wenders) 22/2/10
Man on the Moon (Miloš Forman) 22/3/13
The Cider House Rules (Lasse Hallström) 20/2/13
Björk: All Is Full of Love (Chris Cunningham) 20/3/14
Sunshine (István Szabó) 19/2/15
Go (Doug Liman) 19/3/16

The Max Fischer Players Present: The Truman Show (Wes Anderson) 18/2/13
菊次郎の夏 [Kikujirō no natsu] (Takeshi Kitano) 14/2/16
Cradle Will Rock (Tim Robbins) 11/2/19
Limbo (John Sayles) 9/2/19
Whiteboyz (Marc Levin) 4/2/23

ORPHANS

Film (Director) highest ranking

The Mayfair Set (Adam Curtis & Annabel Hobley) 13
Juha (Aki Kaurismäki) 14
月光の囁き [Gekkō no sasayaki] [Moonlight Whispers] (Akihiko Shiota) 21
Breakfast of Champions (Alan Rudolph) 17
Старик и море [Starik i more] [The Old Man and the Sea] (Aleksandr Petrov) 23
Häjyt [The Tough Ones] (Aleksi Mäkelä) 24
Ich war Hitlers Bodyguard [I Was Hitler's Bodyguard] (Alexander Kluge) 23
New Waterford Girl (Allan Moyle) 21
Besat [Possessed] (Anders Rønnow Klarlund) 21
Ride with the Devil (Ang Lee) 20
Mercury Rev: Opus 40 (Anton Corbijn) 24
El coronel no tiene quien le escriba [No One Writes to the Colonel] (Arturo Ripstein) 8
Beyond the Mat (Barry W. Blaustein) 21
Solas [Alone] (Benito Zambrano) 1
City Walk (Bill Morrison) 8
花ガール [Hanagirl] [Flowergirl] (Cate Shortland) 15
La Nouvelle Ève [The New Eve] (Catherine Corsini) 4
Leftfield: Afrika Shox (Chris Cunningham) 13
Nissan: Instruments + Engine (1999-2000) (Chris Cunningham) 7
The Target Shoots First (Christopher Wilcha) 25
True Crime (Clint Eastwood) 8
Muppets from Space (David Hill) 10
Peau neuve [New Dawn] (Émilie Deleuze) 10
C'est quoi la vie? [What's Life?] (François Dupeyron) 20
Les Amants criminels [Criminal Lovers] (François Ozon) 24
The Green Mile (Frank Darabont) 15
Une liaison pornographique [An Affair of Love] (Frédéric Fonteyne) 2
Otomo (Frieder Schlaich) 16
Blur: Coffee & TV (Garth Jennings) 13
Supergrass: Pumping on Your Stereo (Garth Jennings) 22
Tumbleweeds (Gavin O'Connor) 20
Star Wars: The Phantom Menace (George Lucas) 15
Splendor (Gregg Araki) 20
Two Hands (Gregor Jordan) 16
Flores de otro mundo [Flowers from Another World] (Icíar Bollaín) 7
Girl, Interrupted (James Mangold) 22
Pelíšky [Cosy Dens] (Jan Hřebejk) 14
Lost Motion (Janie Geiser) 17
Les Enfants du marais [The Children of the Marshland] (Jean Becker) 3
October Sky (Joe Johnston) 16
8mm (Joel Schumacher) 20
The Thomas Crown Affair (John McTiernan) 12
暗戰 [Am zin] [Running Out of Time] (Johnnie To) 13
Jamiroquai: Canned Heat (Jonas Åkerlund) 15
One Day in September (Kevin Macdonald) 18
Mystery Men (Kinka Usher) 17
Lola und Bilidikid [Lola and Billy the Kid] (Kutluğ Ataman) 5
Ressources humaines [Human Resources] (Laurent Cantet) 8
Post Mortem (Louis Bélanger) 11
Made Men (Louis Morneau) 25
Arlington Road (Mark Pellington) 18
Cremaster 2 (Matthew Barney) 8
Drop Dead Gorgeous (Michael Patrick Jann) 24
Twin Falls Idaho (Michael Polish) 20
La Maladie de Sachs (Michel Deville) 4
Miss Julie (Mike Figgis) 15
Nekem lámpást adott kezembe az Úr Pesten [The Lord's Lantern in Budapest] (Miklós Jancsó) 13
御法度 [Gohatto] [Taboo] (Nagisa Ōshima) 12
The Hurricane (Norman Jewison) 9
American Pie (Paul Weitz) 18
เรื่องตลก 69 [Ruang talok 69] [6ixtynin9] (Pen-Ek Ratanaruang) 10
8½ Women (Peter Greenaway) 17
Le Vent de la nuit [The Wind of the Night] (Philippe Garrel) 23
Idle Hands (Rodman Flender) 24
Ein Lied von Liebe und Tod [Gloomy Sunday] (Rolf Schübel) 14
Raphael Saadiq: Get Involved (Sanji) 14
Thick as Thieves (Scott Sanders) 16
Haut les cœurs! [Battle Cries] (Sólveig Anspach) 22
Mifunes sidste sang [Mifune] (Søren Kragh-Jacobsen) 8
喜劇之王 [Hei kek ji wong] [King of Comedy] (Stephen Chow & Lee Lik-chi) 15
Lake Placid (Steve Miner) 4
雨あがる [Ame agaru] [After the Rain] (Takashi Koizumi) 15
Ba mùa [Three Seasons] (Tony Bui) 19
Tuvalu (Veit Helmer) 18
The Max Fischer Players Present: Armageddon (Wes Anderson) 25
House on Haunted Hill (William Malone) 10
草房子 [Cao fang zi] [Thatched Memories] (Xu Geng) 23
刑法第三十九条 [Keihō dai sanjūkyū jō] [Article 39] (Yoshimitsu Morita) 1
黒い家 [Kuroi ie] [The Black House] (Yoshimitsu Morita) 10

25 lists submitted

Thanks swo!

1. Eyes Wide Shut
2. Bringing Out The Dead
3. Charisma
4. La maladie de Sachs
5. The Virgin Suicides
6. Outer Space
7. La lettre
8. eXistenZ
9. The Straight Story
10. Jesus’ Son

I bumped Ghost Dog from my top ten at the last minute, but I see it didn't need my help! Late-period Deville, on the other hand..

Merci swo

Surprised that the Gondry video finished so low, and that Mifune was orphaned— I guess this one really has left the cinephile consciousness, at least until some boutique rescues it (it was with Sony, so potentially licensable, no?)

I'll admit that I forgot Mifune existed, but it would've made my list