criterionforum.org

Posted: **Fri Dec 25, 2020 8:45 am**

The deleted scenes actually reinforce just how good the theatrical cut of the film already was. Most of the Missing Pieces footage is extraneous though the extended convenience store sequence has excellent value as Twin Peaks lore and would have made the Philadelphia scenes with Bowie easier to follow. The Deer Meadow section is fine as it is in the film. Even in the second half, there isn't really anything that is truly essential though I do miss the Laura under the fan sequence as originally filmed. I think you could argue that a Director's Cut needn't be substantially longer, and the various fan edits online that reinserted everything back in are bloated pieces that completely miss the point of FWWM. I had a go at a fan edit myself when the box set was released and I ended up only adding 10-12 mins back in (Jeffries in Argentina, the entire convenience store scene, the Palmers talking Norwegian, Laura under the fan).

The drive to Partyland clarifies that the scene is meant to be happening in Canada but if you add that back in, you lose the impact of that hard sudden cut from the Roadhouse to the loud orgy. Admittedly, some dialogue in the film makes only sense with related deleted scenes reinstated (Donna offers Laura a muffin after her breakdown and Laura calls herself a muffin when she leaves the Hayward house in tears; whereas in the film itself, Laura's "I'm a muffin" line at Partyland is a big "huh?" moment). I love FWWM. I think it's Lynch's best film ahead of Mulholland Drive and Eraserhead but I'm the first one to admit that its script is pretty messy compared to those two (as is Wild at Heart; Lynch wasn't the most disciplined writer in the early 90s).

Posted: **Fri Dec 25, 2020 8:50 am**

The Lee and Badalamenti interviews are fine (I especially liked his performance of The Voice of Love at the end) but if you've watched them speak about Twin Peaks before, there is literally very little you don't already know. I attended Comic Con in May 2019 when Sheryl and Ray (Wise) came to a Peaks panel, and I subsequently watched other panels with them, and they pretty much talk about the same things every time. I must say, I respect Ray Wise for how game he is: every single time he gets asked to perform his song from Episode 8 (the Season 2 opener) and he does it admirably but I kinda wonder if he is not heartily sick of it by now.

Posted: **Fri Dec 25, 2020 12:21 pm**

Big Ben wrote: Fri Dec 25, 2020 3:59 amDo you see them as deleted scenes? I'm under the impression that Lynch sees them as canonical but simply couldn't fit them into the feature at the time. Thinking on them myself they felt more like extra bits of clarification/context. I'm unsure how I feel about them outside of that.

In a purely technical sense they are but I do realize they are much more than that, and there is some coherency in how they all fit in sequentially as almost an alternate movie to this. I haven't seen the fan edit yet, but I'm interested in how it all fits together.

Posted: **Sat Dec 26, 2020 9:06 pm**

Finch wrote: Fri Dec 25, 2020 8:50 amI must say, I respect Ray Wise for how game he is: every single time he gets asked to perform his song from Episode 8 (the Season 2 opener) and he does it admirably but I kinda wonder if he is not heartily sick of it by now.

He did a nice A.V. Club interview in 2008, and I forgot that he used to play so many heavies - playing the "possessed" side of his role wasn't a stretch given that experience, but just about every role I've seen him do outside of Twin Peaks since exudes a natural gentleness. Even a role like his defense lawyer in Larry Sanders had this quality - it's not anywhere in his lines, he just has an aura of a really decent person. When you see him in interviews, it feels like it's just his natural personality.

Posted: **Sun Dec 27, 2020 12:26 am**

He was great at that in the third season of Fargo

Posted: **Sun Dec 27, 2020 3:49 am**

hearthesilence wrote: Sat Dec 26, 2020 9:06 pm he just has an aura of a really decent person. When you see him in interviews, it feels like it's just his natural personality.

He was very kind to everyone. We spoke briefly about filming Robocop with Paul Verhoeven and his regret that he wasn't in The Return more (though really Leland's arc was done, what more could they have done with that character? If Unrecorded Night is Twin Peaks under a different name, I think it'd be fun to see Ray returning as a new character). He was very reluctant to do the murder scene in Episode 14 initially because he had just had a baby daughter but Lynch convinced him to do it.

Posted: **Mon Dec 28, 2020 3:45 pm**

Finch wrote: Fri Dec 25, 2020 8:45 am(Donna offers Laura a muffin after her breakdown and Laura calls herself a muffin when she leaves the Hayward house in tears; whereas in the film itself, Laura's "I'm a muffin" line at Partyland is a big "huh?" moment).

It's weird to think of anyone getting stuck on that line, amidst a film (and a larger body of work) filled with non-sequitirs and absolutely inexplicable things. Does "I am the great went" make any more sense?

Posted: **Tue Dec 29, 2020 12:12 am**

Oh I wasn't meaning necessarily to single out that one line but I realise it may have come across that way. As much as I love the film some lines make me cringe a lot ("gobble, gobble" etc, some of Cooper's dialogue, too).

Posted: **Wed Dec 30, 2020 11:47 pm**

Oh, I didn't mean to single you out -- just expressing my amusement at those who prefer to have the things in the film "explained" better via the left-out scenes, when I would think in order to appreciate Twin Peaks in most of its incarnations you need to be ready to allow much of it to be totally inexplicable.

Posted: **Thu Oct 13, 2022 3:06 pm**

podcast with the film's sound supervisor Douglas Murray

I'd love to hear the sound they originally put together for the train car scene.

Posted: **Wed Dec 28, 2022 11:10 pm**

Potemkine French UHD coming April 18th 2023

If French subs aren't enforced, this will do if CC don't follow suit.

Posted: **Sat Jan 06, 2024 4:16 am**

Possible tease for a UHD

Posted: **Sat Jan 06, 2024 1:26 pm**

Pieter at the BR forum found an Amazon France listing for a The Straight Story UHD but I don't imagine CC doing two Lynch films in the same month.

Posted: **Sat Jan 06, 2024 6:14 pm**

And it would be odd for a Criterion release to pop up on Amazon France.

Posted: **Sat Jan 06, 2024 6:38 pm**

Wonder if Kyle did a piece for FWWM as well as Inland Empire at their offices last year. He's only in the film for 10-15 minutes but it'd be nice to hear him talk candidly about the circumstances surrounding his participation in the film. I was always intrigued by his reluctance to appear in the film when it was another opportunity to work with Lynch and after everyone complained how Lynch abandoned the show halfway through season 2. Maybe the burnout was too great at the time. As good as Chris Isaak is, I can't help wondering how the Deer Meadows scenes would have played with Kyle in from the very beginning. The early FWWM drafts suggest that a lot of the scenes with Coop are identical to the Desmond scenes in the finished film. Cooper playing the hot coffee prank on Stanley would have jarred a bit after the show but would have been in line with Coop in the pilot where he comes across as colder than subsequent episodes.

Posted: **Wed Jan 10, 2024 4:11 am**

I'd be very doubtful of that since the pattern has been that Criterion doesn't put extras on the 4K disc (other than commentaries), and doesn't upgrade an existing Blu-ray that they package with the UHD combo, thus no new extras.

Posted: **Tue Oct 29, 2024 8:12 am**

Got a few questions about this film if anyone might know the answers?

- In original theatrical release, did the shot in which Chet Desmond finds the ring fade to white instead of black (as IMDb claims)? If so, did it fade to white on a freeze-frame like the home video versions do? And is there any visual evidence out there?
- Did the theatrical release have English subtitles for the Black Lodge/bar party scenes? Some home video releases have no subtitles for these scenes (e.g. the UK PAL laserdisc).
- Similarly, did the theatrical release have the establishing shots of Theresa Banks' body and the Philadelphia FBI offices captioned with "THERESA BANKS" and "PHILADELPHIA"? Likewise, there's no captions for these shots on some video releases.

Posted: **Sun Jan 19, 2025 4:17 am**

Finch wrote: Fri Dec 25, 2020 8:45 am The deleted scenes actually reinforce just how good the theatrical cut of the film already was. Most of the Missing Pieces footage is extraneous though the extended convenience store sequence has excellent value as Twin Peaks lore and would have made the Philadelphia scenes with Bowie easier to follow. The Deer Meadow section is fine as it is in the film. Even in the second half, there isn't really anything that is truly essential though I do miss the Laura under the fan sequence as originally filmed. I think you could argue that a Director's Cut needn't be substantially longer, and the various fan edits online that reinserted everything back in are bloated pieces that completely miss the point of FWWM. I had a go at a fan edit myself when the box set was released and I ended up only adding 10-12 mins back in (Jeffries in Argentina, the entire convenience store scene, the Palmers talking Norwegian, Laura under the fan).

The drive to Partyland clarifies that the scene is meant to be happening in Canada but if you add that back in, you lose the impact of that hard sudden cut from the Roadhouse to the loud orgy. Admittedly, some dialogue in the film makes only sense with related deleted scenes reinstated (Donna offers Laura a muffin after her breakdown and Laura calls herself a muffin when she leaves the Hayward house in tears; whereas in the film itself, Laura's "I'm a muffin" line at Partyland is a big "huh?" moment). I love FWWM. I think it's Lynch's best film ahead of Mulholland Drive and Eraserhead but I'm the first one to admit that its script is pretty messy compared to those two (as is Wild at Heart; Lynch wasn't the most disciplined writer in the early 90s).

I have seen this fan cut (or one of these) but I first thought since the "file" was named Twin Peaks The Return - Episode 0 "Fire Walks With Me" (complete version) that somewhere in the world (on earth) a complete episode 0 including the missing pieces would have been broadcast - so, all these "complete version" with the outtakes are fan cut ?

In France an UHD + Blu-Ray is coming under the title Fire Walk With Me ("missing pieces"); I suppose that these will be the same outtakes than the Criterion version.

Posted: **Tue Jul 15, 2025 4:08 pm**

4K upgrade in October but sadly it would appear without a Dolby Vision grade.

Posted: **Tue Jul 15, 2025 4:21 pm**

Finch wrote: Tue Jul 15, 2025 4:08 pm 4K upgrade in October but sadly it would appear without a Dolby Vision grade.

Biggest bummer of this batch of announcements (beside Shrouds being relegated to Premieres). Goes from a must buy to a wait and see. This movie would look outstanding with even a standard HDR grade.

Posted: **Tue Jul 15, 2025 4:28 pm**

I assume Lynch died before he could approve one, so they didn't want to start altering the grade without his approval.

Posted: **Tue Jul 15, 2025 4:35 pm**

flyonthewall2983 wrote: Thu Dec 24, 2020 10:37 pm I love the Sheryl Lee interview on this disc. Both the wisdom of age, and having revisited the character again for The Return gave her some really interesting perspective on how she approached the role. I honestly wasn't as over the moon for this as I was other aspects of TP or indeed some of Lynch's other movies, but she gives an incredible performance that completely transcends any deficiencies.

I actually prefer the assembly of deleted scenes over the feature.

Given the amount of time and life that has passed and changed so radically, I still agree with most of this except I have not seen the movie since. Might owe it to myself to revisit it with the new release. The ones for Mulholland Drive and Lost Highway felt more in depth of capturing what perhaps audiences older than me experienced. The 4K work on both merely a tweak to what was already there, but for my eyes so much more.

Posted: **Tue Jul 15, 2025 4:50 pm**

With Criterion’s policy of not altering any masters, they would’ve had to re-do the entire restoration and grade from scratch. As the film is held by mk2, they probably had a say in this too and were perfectly fine with the current 4k master even though it shows its age.

Posted: **Tue Jul 15, 2025 4:56 pm**

I'll have to double-check if Elephant Man and Straight Story had Lynch approved DV grades on the European discs or not. I think it's fair to assume that Wild at Heart won't have a DV grade either if it gets upgraded to 4K.

Posted: **Tue Jul 15, 2025 6:25 pm**

They both are HDR. Straight Story might have been the last 4K transfer he supervised.

criterionforum.org

898 Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

Re: 898 Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

Re: 898 Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

Re: 898 Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

Re: 898 Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

Re: 898 Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

Re: 898 Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

Re: 898 Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

Re: 898 Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

Re: 898 Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

Re: 898 Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

Re: 898 Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

Re: 898 Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

Re: 898 Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

Re: 898 Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

Re: 898 Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

Re: 898 Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

Re: 898 Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

Re: 898 Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

Re: 898 Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

Re: 898 Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

Re: 898 Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

Re: 898 Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

Re: 898 Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

Re: 898 Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

Re: 898 Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me