Paris vu par: R2 vs R4

[OliverB]

Somebody posted screen caps of the French disc in the captions thread in this forum and the pq appeared more than adequate given the source was filmed on 16mm, overall quality seemed quite nice. Here's a review I found with many more screen caps and menu shots.

Now I've come across this R4 release by Madman as well which has the advantage of English subs.

Here is what a DVD reviewer had to say about the comparison of the two editions:

Paris Vu Par… was released in France earlier this year. The R2 France DVD includes the same technical specifications and extra features as the local release plus an additional featurette titled The Screens in the City: interviews with Barbet Schroeder, Jean Rouch and Claude Chabrol (13 minutes). However English subtitles are not available on the R2 France DVD release.

Now I'm from Montreal so my French is fairly decent. Subs are certainly appreciated and preferred, but not at the sacrifice of overall quality. What I'd like to know about, is how the transfers compare and overall presentation of these releases. Should I opt for the R2 or R4 disc? Save for one additional supplementary interview, the features appear to be the same. What's the consensus here?

[OliverB]

thanks david!

I'll take your word for it, no caps needed -- I'm going to order it this week!

thanks again for the affirmation!

[sevenarts]

Thanks for the word on the Madman release, david, that slipped under my radar. I had been anxiously awaiting the now-stalled New Yorker release, but I'm sure that would've been pretty crappy anyway. I'm always on the lookout for more English-subbed Godard, and unlike other anthology films of the time, it sounds like this one has more to offer than the obligatory Godard short.