domino harvey wrote:I must confess I'm no fan of the film, but I wonder if it wouldn't have been better served by taking a page from Columbo and just admitting whodunnit immediately instead of playing coy to an audience that could not possibly be surprised by their reveal
That would only be possible had
Columbo ever killed anybody
. It's no more or less obvious than many other murder mysteries. When I first saw the film at its release I wasn't sure, there were enough red herrings to fool a 15 year old. It's become more obvious since
Tommy Lee Jones
got famous, this must have been one of his first movie roles ? His motive is rather trite though.
In the end I'm not that bothered by the whodunnit element, which becomes irrelevant once you've seen the film. I come back for the grimy glamour of 70s New York, Faye Dunaway and the disco music and I think Irvin Kershner did a stylish job with the film. I even like the Barbra Streisand theme song.